In Ethiopia, an ethnicity is erased

‘Leave no Tigrayan’: In Ethiopia, an ethnicity is erased


April 7, 2021 GMT

HAMDAYET, Sudan (AP) — The atrocities have been seared into the pores and skin and the minds of Tigrayans, who take shelter by the hundreds nearby of the homeland they fled in northern Ethiopia.

They arrive in warmth that soars above 38 C (100 F), carrying the ache of gunshot wounds, torn vaginas, welts on crushed backs. Less seen are the horrors that jolt them awake at evening: Memories of dozens of our bodies strewn on riverbanks. Fighters raping a girl one after the other for talking her personal language. A toddler, weakened by starvation, left behind.

Now, for the primary time, additionally they deliver proof of an official try at what is being known as ethnic cleaning within the type of a brand new id card that eliminates all traces of Tigray, as confirmed to The Associated Press by 9 refugees from completely different communities. Written in a language not their very own, issued by authorities from one other ethnic group, the ID playing cards are the most recent proof of a scientific drive by the Ethiopian authorities and its allies to destroy the Tigrayan individuals.

The Amhara authorities now accountable for the close by metropolis of Humera took Seid Mussa Omar’s authentic ID card displaying his Tigrayan id and burned it, the soft-spoken nurse stated. On his new card examined by the AP, issued in January with the Amharic language, an Amhara stamp and a border of tiny hearts, even the phrase Tigray had vanished.

“I kept it to show the world,” Seid stated. He added that solely 10 Tigrayans remained of the roughly 400 who labored on the hospital the place he had been employed, the remainder killed or fleeing. “This is genocide … Their aim is to erase Tigray.”

What began as a political dispute in certainly one of Africa’s strongest and populous international locations has become a marketing campaign of ethnic cleaning in opposition to minority Tigrayans, in accordance with AP interviews with 30 refugees in Sudan and dozens extra by telephone, together with worldwide consultants. The Ethiopian authorities of Nobel Peace Prize winner Abiy Ahmed is accused of teaming up along with his ethnic group — his mom was Amhara — and troopers from neighboring Eritrea to punish round 6 million individuals. Witnesses say they’ve break up a lot of Tigray between them, with the Amhara within the west and Eritrean forces within the east.

Ethiopia claims that life in Tigray is returning to regular, and Abiy has known as the battle “tiresome.” But the refugees the AP spoke with, together with some who arrived simply hours earlier than, stated abuses had been nonetheless occurring. Almost all described killings, typically of a number of individuals, rapes and the looting and burning of crops that with out large meals assist might tip the area into hunger.


This story was funded by a grant from the Pulitzer Center on Crisis Reporting.


For months, the individuals of Tigray have been largely sealed off from the world, with electrical energy and telecommunication entry severed and cell phones typically seized, leaving little to again up their claims of hundreds, even tens of hundreds, killed. That has begun to vary.

U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken asserted final month that “ethnic cleansing” has taken place in western Tigray, marking the primary time a prime official within the worldwide neighborhood has overtly described the state of affairs as such. The time period refers to forcing a inhabitants from a area by means of expulsions and different violence, typically together with killings and rapes.

Refugees advised the AP that Amhara authorities and allied forces in western Tigray have taken over complete communities, ordering Tigrayans out or rounding them up. A refugee from Humera, Goitom Hagos, stated he noticed hundreds of Tigrayans loaded into vans and doesn’t know what occurred to them.

The Amhara now management some authorities workplaces in western Tigray and determine who belongs — and even whether or not Tigrayans exist in any respect. Some had been ordered to simply accept the Amhara id or go away, and others had been advised to depart anyway, the refugees stated.

Lemlem Gebrehiwet was pressured to flee whereas closely pregnant and gave start three days after reaching Sudan. She recalled the brand new authorities telling her, “This is Amhara.”

Shy, her child lady ready, she struggled to understand. “Maybe we did something wrong.”

Seid, the nurse, fled Humera early within the battle after his hospital got here beneath heavy shelling, with the wounded carried in screaming and colleagues killed. He returned in January within the hope that situations had improved, as Abiy’s authorities promised.

They hadn’t. His dwelling had been looted, and the remaining Tigrayans had shrunk to a quiet inhabitants of the aged, ladies and kids who had been discouraged from talking their very own language, Tigrinya.

At the hospital, Tigrayans needed to pay for care, in contrast to the Amhara. Anyone who got here was allowed to talk Amharic solely. Tigrayan staffers weren’t paid, and each evening there was gunfire.

Ten days after returning to the hospital, Seid left for Sudan. Now, at this dusty publish, refugees go blazing days sprawled on plastic mats beneath shelters of woven straw. They keep perilously near the border within the hope that lacking family members will emerge from Tigray.


The battle started in November as a political conflict of previous and current, with all of Ethiopia arguably at stake.

Tigray leaders had dominated the nation’s authorities for practically three a long time, making a system of ethnic-based regional states. But when Abiy took office in 2018, he moved to centralize energy. He sidelined the Tigray leaders and made peace with Eritrea after years of struggle, incomes a Nobel Peace Prize.

After final year’s election was delayed, the defiant Tigray leaders seen Abiy’s mandate as unlawful and held their very own vote. The authorities then opened a army offensive, saying Tigray forces had attacked a army base.

“The federal government is trying to be king. We Tigrayans refuse,” stated one refugee, Nega Chekole.

In response to allegations that the Amhara are ordering Tigrayans to depart and issuing new ID playing cards, the spokeswoman for the prime minister’s office, Billene Seyoum, stated the realm is beneath a provisional administration “who are all from the region.”

The Ethiopian authorities says it rejects “any and all notions and practices of ethnic cleansing” and can by no means tolerate such practices, “nor will it turn a blind eye to such crimes.” However, nearly everybody the AP interviewed stated that they had watched fellow Tigrayans being killed or seen our bodies on the bottom.

In her city of greater than a dozen ethnic teams, Belaynesh Beyene was dealt a ghastly lesson in simply how little Tigrayans all of the sudden had been value.

In the early days of the combating, she stated she noticed 24 our bodies within the streets of Dansha in western Tigray. The 58-year-old grandmother and different residents had been prevented from burying them by the Amhara youth militia, a apply that witnesses throughout Tigray have reported as an added insult to grief. The apply applies solely to Tigrayan corpses.

“They accidentally killed an ethnic Oromo in a Tigrayan household,” she stated. “When they realized their ‘mistake,’ they came and buried him.”

A spokesman for the Amhara regional authorities, Gizachew Muluneh, didn’t answer questions from the AP. The Amhara have stated they’re taking again land they declare belongs to them.

Soldiers from Eritrea, lengthy an enemy of Tigray’s now-fugitive leaders, have additionally been blamed for a number of the worst human rights abuses. Under strain, Abiy stated final month the troopers will go away, after lengthy denying their presence.

Hiwot Hadush, a trainer from Zalambessa, stated scores of individuals had been killed after the Eritreans went home to deal with, opening fireplace.

“Even if someone was dead, they shot them again, dozens of times. I saw this,” she stated. “I saw many bodies, even priests. They killed all Tigrayans.”

In one other border neighborhood, Irob, furnishings maker Awalom Mebrahtom described hiding and watching Eritrean troopers order 18 Tigrayans, largely younger males like him, to lie in a distant subject. They had been shot to dying.

The killings proceed. In early March, after months on the run, 30-year-old Alem Mebrahtu tried a determined crossing of the Tekeze river. Separated from her three young children within the early chaos of the battle, she had heard they had been in Sudan.

Sympathetic ladies from the Wolkait ethnic group pleaded with Eritrean troopers close to the river to let Alem cross, whereas urging her to fake to be Wolkait, too. It labored, however she noticed a grim reminder of what might have occurred if she had failed.

Bodies lay scattered close to the riverbank, she stated. She estimated round 50 corpses.

“Some were face-down. Some were looking up at the sky,” she stated.

Exhaustion nonetheless pressed deep beneath her eyes, Alem began to cry. There by the river, confronted with dying, tears hadn’t been allowed. The Eritrean troopers beat individuals for expressing grief, she stated.

Samrawit Weldegerima, who had arrived simply two weeks earlier in Hamdayet, additionally noticed corpses by the river, counting seven. Freshly branded on their temples had been the markings some Tigrayans have to precise their id, she stated.

“When I saw them, I was terrified,” Samrawit stated, touching her stomach, six months pregnant. “I thought I was already dead.”

Those who crossed the river had been amazed to seek out that the Amhara had been now in cost in western Tigray. Alem’s dwelling in Humera was occupied by Amhara militia. She requested them for her garments, however that they had been burned. She was advised to get out.

Reluctantly, to guard herself, she is making an attempt to study Amharic.

“Their aim is to leave no Tigrayan,” she stated. “I hope there will be a Tigray for my children to go home to.”

The concept of dwelling stays harmful. Days after Abiy urged individuals in Tigray to return in late March, at the very least two males making an attempt to take action from Hamdayet had been fatally shot nearby of the border crossing.

They had been buried by lots of of refugees on the Orthodox church in Hamdayet, the place the clean partitions are being mapped for murals of sacrifice and salvation. Some of the devoted drop to their knees and clutch the stones, deep in prayer. Others relaxation their foreheads in opposition to the doorway, as if they will’t go on.


Even because the Amhara fighters took turns raping her, they provided the younger girl a twisted path to what they thought-about redemption.

She had returned to her looted dwelling in Humera. There, she was seized by militia members talking Amharic. When she requested them to talk her native Tigrinya, which she understood much better, they turned offended and began kicking her.

She fell, they usually fell upon her. She remembers at the very least three males.

“Let the Tigray government come and help you,” she recalled them saying.

They additionally made her a proposal: “Claim to be Amhara and we’ll give you back your house and find you a husband. But if you claim to be Tigrayan, we will come and rape you again.”

The girl’s Amhara neighbor was current throughout the assault. When she later approached him for assist, there was none.

“So what?” she recalled him saying. “You came back. Behave and be quiet.”

The girl cried all evening. The subsequent day, she discovered little consolation in studying that many others in her neighborhood had been raped, too.

“One mother and daughter had been forced to watch each other,” she stated. “One woman was raped on the road, with people watching. Other accounts were worse than mine.”

She left for Sudan. It was mid-February. Afraid to talk with anybody, she waited nearly a month earlier than in search of medical care.

“I was ashamed,” she stated, and began to cry. She watched the doorway warily, fearing the rumors that may unfold among the many refugees.

She stated she was grateful to be HIV-negative, however she is pregnant. For a protracted second, she was silent. She can hardly take into consideration that but. Her household again dwelling doesn’t know.

The United Nations has stated greater than 500 rapes in Tigray have been reported to well being care staff. But the lady from Humera, whose account was confirmed by her physician, assumes many extra survivors are hiding it simply as she did. The AP doesn’t title individuals who have been sexually abused.

Several refugees from completely different Tigray communities advised the AP they watched or listened helplessly as ladies had been taken away by Amhara or Eritrean fighters and raped. It was like taunting, stated Adhanom Gebrehanis from Korarit village, who had simply arrived in Hamdayet with the welts from a beating by Eritrean troopers on his again.

“They do these things openly to make us ashamed,” he stated.

He described watching Eritreans pull apart 20 ladies from a bunch of Tigrayans and rape them. The subsequent day, 13 of the ladies had been returned.

“Go,” Adhanom stated the Eritreans advised the others. “We already have what we want.”

A midwife from Adwa, Elsa Tesfa Berhe, described treating ladies secretly after Eritrean troopers swept by means of well being facilities, looting even the beds and telling sufferers to depart. As Berhe snuck out to ship infants and take care of the wounded, she noticed individuals making an attempt to bury our bodies on the threat of being shot, or pouring alcohol on corpses in an try to cover the scent.

With the well being facilities destroyed, little if any care stays for girls and ladies who’ve been raped. No one is aware of what number of now carry the kids of their attackers.

Berhe had simply arrived in Sudan. She cried as she recalled a 60-year-old girl who was raped vaginally and anally by Eritrean troopers after which waited for days, making an attempt to cover the bleeding, earlier than in search of assist.

“She didn’t want to tell anyone,” Berhe stated. She heard the lady ask, “Can anyone trust me if I say I was raped?”

Another girl was raped by 4 Eritrean troopers whereas her husband hid beneath the mattress, Berhe stated. Her husband recounted the assault after they sought an abortion.

A 3rd girl described how Eritrean troopers ordered her father to rape her, then shot and killed him when he refused. The troopers raped her as an alternative.

Berhe fears that the state of affairs in rural areas is even worse, as described by the displaced individuals arriving in cities. So far, few from the surface world can attain the areas the place nearly all of Tigrayans lived earlier than the battle, as combating continues.

“Do you think there is a word to explain this? There is no word,” stated a midwife from Humera, who gave solely her first title, Mulu.

In Hamdayet she befriended seven ladies from the identical village, Mai Gaba, who stated they had been raped individually by numerous fighters, together with Ethiopian federal forces. Mulu fears that Mai Gaba is a conservative instance and estimates that some communities have seen scores of assaults.

“This is to harm the community psychologically,” Mulu stated. “Most of the people in Tigray support the (fugitive Tigray leaders). To destroy them, you must destroy Tigrayans.”


There is extra to return.

Almost each particular person interviewed described a worrying scarcity of meals, and a few stated Tigrayans are being starved. Many recalled seeing crops being looted or burned in communities by Amhara or Eritrean fighters, a toll that even exhibits up in satellite tv for pc imagery.

Kidu Gebregirgis, a farmer, stated he was questioned nearly every day about his ethnicity, his shirt yanked apart to examine for marks from the strap of a gun. He stated the Amhara harvested round 5,000 kilograms (5.5 quick tons) of sorghum from his fields and hauled it away, a process that took two weeks. He shook his head in amazement.

The battle started shortly earlier than the harvest within the largely agricultural area. Now the planting season approaches.

“But there is no seed,” Kidu stated. “There’s nothing to start again.”

The prospect is terrifying, stated Alex de Waal, the creator of a brand new report warning of mass hunger in Tigray and a researcher on the Fletcher School at Tufts University.

“What I fear is that millions of people are in the rural areas, staying because they are hopeful they will be able to plant,” he stated. “If they’re not able to plant, if food supplies run out, then all of a sudden we could see a mass migration.”

Tigrayans who handed by means of rural communities described ravenous individuals, typically aged, begging outdoors church buildings. Sometimes they did, too.

Alem, the exhausted mom, begged for money and tightened her garments to regulate the starvation pangs. Abedom, a day laborer who solely gave one title, begged whereas roaming the mountains and villages for 3 months.

“It was normal to go a whole day without food,” he stated. “So many people were hungry. They loot everything, so if they take it all, how do I survive?”

The starvation was staggering. One refugee noticed a person faint on the highway in Adi Asr, near dying. Another described a fellow traveler so drained he merely stopped strolling. Yet one other noticed a toddler, too weak to go on, left behind.

Again, ethnicity was essential. Belaynesh, from Dansha, stated she made positive to talk Amharic when approaching farmhouses in western Tigray for meals.

Ethiopia, beneath worldwide strain, has stated meals assist has been distributed to greater than 4 million individuals in Tigray. Refugees disagreed, saying they noticed no such factor of their communities or asserting that meals was being diverted.

Maza Girmay, 65, stated she heard meals was being distributed, so she went to the federal government office in her neighborhood of Bahkar to inquire.

“They told me, ‘Go home, you’re Tigrayan,’” she stated. “We Tigrayans are Ethiopian. Why do they treat us as non-Ethiopian?”

The rejection introduced her to tears. An Orthodox cross tattooed on her brow, lengthy light from childhood, wrinkled together with her sorrow.

In the neighborhood of Division, farmer Berhane Gebrewahid stated he was shot by Amhara fighters in search of his cattle. He stated meals assist was distributed in February by Amhara authorities however refused to Tigrayans, together with him. Even the title of his homeland had been modified to Northern Gondar, after a serious metropolis in Amhara.

A colonel with the Tigray fighters, Bahre Tebeje, anxious that hunger will kill extra individuals than the struggle itself.

“Most food aid returns to the Amhara and Eritreans,” he asserted, leaning ahead intently, a tattered black-and-white kaffiyeh round his neck. “It’s not being distributed to the people.”

Severe malnutrition is already above emergency ranges as humanitarian staff rush to succeed in communities, the U.N. has stated. In Hamdayet, a handful of such circumstances had been lately despatched to a regional hospital for remedy, in accordance with a physician there. One girl, recovering, nonetheless couldn’t produce milk for her child, who whimpered and sucked at a limp breast.

Battered and hungry, Tigrayans nonetheless arrive every day on the border publish the place Sudanese troopers watch a no man’s land within the shadow of a fading flag. One latest night, the AP noticed three new refugees approaching.

In Sudan, the Tigrayans are registered and requested for his or her ethnicity. For as soon as, they’re free to answer.

Back to top button