Three of the states bordering the Navajo Nation have recorded constructive circumstances of chronic wasting disease, threatening elk and deer herds each on the reservation and in Arizona.
The tribal nation, which spans Arizona, Utah and New Mexico and borders Colorado, is taken into account a high-risk space for an outbreak. The contagious brain disease, which impacts elk and deer, can quickly unfold via a herd; an an infection at all times ends in dying.
Though there have been no circumstances of the disease transferring from an animal to a human, each cultural practices and conservation funding are in danger if an outbreak happens among the many Navajo Nation’s already-threatened herds.
Gloria Tom, the director of the Navajo Nation Department of Fish and Wildlife, stated warming climate and drier seasons have already taken a toll on elk and deer.
“We are mandated by Navajo law to manage, protect and conserve,” Tom said. “If we lose our herds because of disease and climate change, we would not be fulfilling our mandated responsibilities. It would be a failure on our part.”
Surveillance via test stations throughout the reservation is presently the most used safeguard towards the disease. The tribal wildlife company is partnering with the Arizona Game and Fish Department for each surveillance and the event of a response plan within the occasion of a constructive case.
“It’s likely that there have been deer with CWD that have moved onto the nation at some point. Whether that has infected our resident deer or significantly affected our deer, I can’t say,” stated Jessica Fort, a wildlife biologist for the Navajo Nation. “But if, or when it does come, we’ll be ready.”
Preparing for an outbreak
The National Wildlife Health Center has tracked constructive circumstances of chronic wasting disease in free-ranging elk and deer herds in southern Utah, which encompasses a part of the Navajo Nation.
The first constructive case in Utah was found in 2002 and up to date knowledge from the Utah Division of Wildlife Services reveals the state has had over 115 constructive circumstances since.
With circumstances by the border, Fort says there’s a greater potential for an contaminated deer or elk to cross into the Navajo Nation. She predicts that “If it hasn’t happened, it’ll probably happen in the next 10 years.”
Neither the Navajo Nation nor Arizona has recorded a constructive case of chronic wasting disease in an area animal. But due to its proximity to contaminated herds, the Navajo Nation is taken into account a high-risk space.
Fort is presently drafting a response plan within the occasion of an outbreak.
She stated the doc “contains actions to take after we receive our first CWD confirmation, as it’s likely just a matter of time.” It additionally outlines “steps to take to attempt to eradicate CWD from the area it’s first detected, and if that does not work, a plan for CWD management.”
During final year’s searching season, three test stations collected roughly 40 samples from hunters harvesting elk and deer throughout the Navajo Nation.
The tribal wildlife company made it obligatory for individuals searching in some areas alongside the Utah-Arizona state line to test of their deer.
But in keeping with Fort, just one individual of 31 “tagged out,” that means had a profitable hunt. She attributes the dearth of success to “inclement weather and unpredictable movement of deer across Navajo-Utah borders.”
A low hunter success rate additionally meant fewer samples for chronic wasting disease testing.
“We’ve never had a positive sample but that doesn’t mean it’s not here yet,” Fort stated. “We have a pretty small sample size each year. That’s not enough for the area that we have, to get a good idea if there is CWD in the nation.”
The Navajo Nation is the most important reservation within the U.S. at barely greater than 27,000 sq. miles. The tribal wildlife company companions with the Arizona Game and Fish Department for chronic wasting disease sampling.
“There are a lot of potential impacts from CWD that make it difficult to ascertain what will happen. But waiting for something to happen, so you can react to it, is not the best plan. That’s why we’re conducting surveillance, so we can attempt to address it before it becomes firmly established,” stated Todd Buck, a wildlife supervisor for the Arizona wildlife division, who has been stationed on the Kaibab Plateau for almost three a long time.
Over the final 4 sampling seasons, Navajo officers have examined over 360 samples; almost 30% of these samples had been taken within the 2019-20 season.
“There is very prominent intermingling of deer that summer in Utah and deer that summer in the Kaibab along the state border,” Buck said. “Those two herds intermingle every winter. As a result, it’s an area where it’s likely, if CWD does make it into the state, to occur.”
To more accurately assure the nation’s integrity from chronic wasting disease, Fort estimates it would take the testing of around 500 samples every season.
According to Fort, the Navajo Nation’s department of fish and wildlife is currently discussing the possibility of expanding the areas where deer checks are mandated.
“We just received news that Colorado Parks and Wildlife has detected CWD in several populations in the Four Corners region, which is very concerning for us,” Fort said. “We have not decided anything concrete yet.”
Chronic wasting disease affects cervids, like deer and elk, by causing severe brain degeneration and declining bodily function. It’s a prion disease with similarities to mad cow disease, which is scientifically known as bovine spongiform encephalopathy.
While chronic wasting disease has not been found to infect humans, its similarity to mad cow disease has led the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to advise hunters to be careful when handling harvested elk and deer and to get the animal tested before eating it.
Mule deer is a “very significant” a part of the Navajo individuals’s food plan, in keeping with Tom. She stated a constructive case of the disease might result in concern of a higher outbreak and will scare individuals from consuming deer meat, which could be robust for a lot of households that depend on this meals supply.
“One of the basic concepts of the Navajo belief is that the people are here using resources from Mother Earth,” Tom said. “Because of that, we strive to continue to be in balance with nature. We need to be in balance with everything around us in order for us to have a meaningful life.”
“Chronic wasting disease would disrupt this balance because it would prevent us from using those animals… if confirmed here, CWD would have a pretty significant impact on the culture,” Tom stated.
The meat shouldn’t be the one necessary a part of the mule deer to the Navajo individuals. Tom stated components of the animal — the disguise, antlers and fats — are additionally used for ceremonial functions.
“The Navajo people have relied heavily on our natural resources, like elk and deer,” Tom stated. “They are traditionally and culturally important to us as a people. The resources were put here for the people to use and we use it in all aspects… it is an integral part of our everyday life.”
Besides the cultural penalties, an outbreak of chronic wasting disease might additionally harm the company’s conservation efforts.
Like many state companies, the income collected from searching permits funds wildlife administration packages within the nation. These packages create employment alternatives for individuals on the reservation and help packages for struggling species.
Tom believes the priority surrounding the disease would have a “significant impact on those revenues.” An outbreak might additionally deal a very devastating blow to the reservation’s wildlife as a result of it will “compound the effects of climate change.”
“How significant of a blow? We don’t know. But we’ve seen major declines in our deer populations and we’re trying to figure out how to help what is happening,” Tom stated. “And an outbreak would only make it worse.”
Environmental protection on azcentral.com and in The Arizona Republic is supported by a grant from the Nina Mason Pulliam Charitable Trust. Follow The Republic environmental reporting crew at setting.azcentral.com and @azcenvironment on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.