Should you get identity theft safety? Here’s what it does

If you’d requested me in 2018 whether or not I used to be prone to be a sufferer of identity theft, I’d have stated no.

I used free credit score monitoring. I had distinctive passwords and two-factor authentication on all my financial institution accounts and the e-mail tackle that these accounts had been linked to. I didn’t preserve any personal figuring out info in my pockets apart from my driver’s license. I used to be tech-savvy and financially conscientious.
But after my pockets received stolen, it occurred to me. It was a nightmare. And it may occur to you.

I wrote a narrative about my expertise, together with methods to guard your self and what to do in case your identity is stolen. I additionally proposed some options that might make this crime tougher to commit within the first place, and simpler for victims after it does occur.

One factor I didn’t write about: ID theft insurance coverage. Before my saga, I hadn’t used LifeLock or Aura or any service like that. I didn’t actually know what they did, or whether or not they would have been useful in my scenario. But after my story got here out, I began getting loads of emails from readers asking whether or not they need to get it.

So I made a decision to do some digging. Here’s what I discovered, whether or not you ought to contemplate getting identity theft insurance coverage, and whether or not I did.

What does identity theft safety do?

Reddit AMA

Got questions on ID theft?

Join Times assistant editor Jessica Roy for a Reddit AMA (ask me something) about identity theft.

When: Noon PST, Thursday, Dec. 8, 2022
Where: r/IAmA

Identity theft insurance coverage does not fully forestall your identity from being stolen. Think of it extra like AAA, stated Eva Velasquez, the pinnacle of the Identity Theft Resource Center — it’s there to assist you after the actual fact, however it doesn’t imply you’ll by no means blow a tire. Here’s what it does.

Services equivalent to LifeLock monitor your credit score in addition to the usage of your personal info. Free credit score monitoring providers together with Credit Karma and Credit Sesame will monitor the three main credit score bureaus (Equifax, Experian and TransUnion) for you and alert you when new inquiries and contours of credit score seem. In my case, I began receiving emails when the thieves had been making an attempt to open dozens of recent retailer bank cards. ID theft insurance coverage does this too. But there are greater than 100 bureaus that monitor numerous kinds of monetary exercise, together with checking accounts, utilities and payday loans. Identity theft safety providers will monitor these in addition to the three massive gamers, and alert you each time your personal monetary info is used.

David Putnam, the pinnacle of identity for LifeLock — which is the biggest and possibly the best-known service of this type, although definitely not the one one — stated the company has relationships with banks, state governments, and different establishments that enable it to watch prospects’ personal knowledge past what free providers supply. In my case, he stated I’d have been alerted “almost instantly” when the thieves opened checking and financial savings accounts at Bank of America and Wells Fargo.

So identity theft safety will monitor how your monetary identity is being utilized in extra locations than simply the credit score bureaus, and can most likely let you know quicker in case your identity is getting used not directly. That’s one piece of it.

Another piece is dealing with cleanup in case your identity does get stolen. If I’d had ID theft insurance coverage when my identity was stolen, that company would have dealt with the numerous irritating cellphone calls, emails and reviews for me.

The actual particulars would rely on the plan you select, however typically talking, you’re eligible to be reimbursed for any money you lose within the course of of getting your identity stolen, each in lost funds and personal bills, in addition to associated authorized assist — for example, if you had been wrongfully arrested for one thing your identity thief had finished and wanted a lawyer.

Many additionally supply “dark web monitoring” that may inform you when your knowledge comes up on one of many darker corners of the Internet. At this level, everybody’s info is nearly definitely someplace on the darkish internet, and credit score monitoring providers can’t take away it all. But being conscious of it is likely to be reminder to, say, change your password for one thing if it got here up in a leak.

How a lot does identity theft insurance coverage price?

According to a comparison from U.S. News and World Report, identity theft safety will price you about $10 to $40 a month, relying on the plan you choose. But you would possibly already get it totally free or at a reduction by means of your employer, your bank card perks, your financial institution or credit score union, your house owner or renters insurance coverage, or a corporation equivalent to AAA, Costco or AARP.

Also, if you’ve been a sufferer in an information hack — which hundreds of millions of people have at this level — you is likely to be eligible for some type of monitoring from that.

Will it assist in case your identity has already been stolen?

Most identity theft insurance coverage corporations gained’t assist you with issues that occurred earlier than you had a coverage with them. “For the most part the industry doesn’t go backwards,” Putnam stated.

But your supplier will assist you clear up any future incidents, that are nearly inevitable if you’ve been a sufferer of identity theft already. And the monitoring will assist you know sooner when somebody is making an attempt to make use of your identity once more or open one other account.

Should you get identity theft safety?

Even although I’m a sufferer of identity theft, I don’t suppose everybody essentially must pay for identity theft insurance coverage. Would it have helped me? Yes. But if I had frozen my credit score earlier than the thieves received their fingers on my pockets, they most likely would have had bother opening any new checking accounts. Because I used free credit score monitoring and acted shortly, I used to be capable of foil them earlier than they might take out any bank cards in my identify. They nonetheless would have been ready to make use of my driver’s license, as a result of California does not flag licenses which were reported stolen to banks or regulation enforcement.

“There are really powerful ways to protect yourself for free, and you don’t need to sign up for these services to have this protection,” stated Kimberly Palmer, a personal finance knowledgeable for NerdWallet. (Keep studying to see what these free strategies are.)

If you’re prepared to watch your credit score intently and take care of the fallout in case your identity does get stolen, then you won’t want an extra insurance coverage coverage. The New York Times declared “most people shouldn’t pay for identity theft protection” again in 2020.

But if you are at excessive danger of identity theft, you ought to contemplate it. The No. 1 danger issue: being a earlier sufferer. People who’re aged or who’ve had their personal knowledge compromised in an information breach are additionally at increased danger. If you’re in a kind of teams, consider your price range and your willingness to dig your self out from below another person’s crime heap, and make your choice accordingly.

Even if you do select to enroll, “it doesn’t mean you can abdicate all responsibility” for preserving your identity secure, Velasquez stated. You nonetheless have to follow good personal knowledge hygiene, equivalent to keeping track of your financial institution statements and utilizing safe passwords.

How do you select which identity theft insurance coverage to purchase?

First, double-check whether or not you already get it totally free or at a reduced rate by means of your job (verify together with your human resources division), your insurance coverage (name customer support), a monetary establishment equivalent to your credit score union or by means of a bank card, or as a good thing about an information breach settlement.

When you’re looking for an off-the-shelf plan, “make sure you understand what you’re signing up for,” Palmer stated. “Providers offer different layers or tiers. Are you getting just monitoring, active alerts, meaningful recovery, what exactly will they help you with? Are you signing up for a more simple version or a higher-end version?”

In some circumstances, probably the most fundamental tier of plans are simply credit score monitoring, which you can do your self totally free. You need to ensure you’re getting enhanced personal info monitoring and have entry to assist in case your identity will get stolen.

You can evaluate plans and value comparisons at NerdWallet, U.S. News and World Report, CNBC, and CNET.

How to forestall identity theft

There are fairly a number of steps you can take to guard your identity with out spending any money. You can do each single one in all these items and nonetheless change into a sufferer of identity theft — however they’ll go a great distance towards stopping it.

  1. Freeze your credit score with the three main credit score bureaus. It solely took me quarter-hour to do that with Equifax, TransUnion and Experian, and even much less time to unfreeze my credit score once I wanted to. It is free to freeze and unfreeze your credit score — you don’t want any paid “upgrades.”
  2. Use distinctive passwords and two-factor authentication wherever potential. Yes, it’s annoying to attend 10 seconds for a textual content message when you log into your checking account. But that tiny wrinkle of friction provides a serious barrier to anybody who would attempt to achieve entry to it. In my case, the thieves had been by no means capable of get into my financial institution accounts or my electronic mail, regardless of a number of makes an attempt.
  3. Sign up for alerts out of your financial institution. Configure it so you get a textual content or electronic mail (or each) each time somebody does one thing to your account, equivalent to altering your password or including a brand new account. I used to be alerted immediately when my thieves tried to open a brand new checking account at one in all my banks.
  4. Check your financial institution statements. Look at your financial institution and bank card transactions recurrently and name if you see something funky. The sooner you tackle it, the higher the possibility that the cost could be reversed.
  5. Check your credit score report. You are eligible to obtain a free copy of your credit score report as soon as a year from every of the three main bureaus. You can request all three directly, or space them out in the course of the year. Make certain there’s nothing on there you don’t acknowledge.
  6. Don’t carry your Social Security card in your pockets. Yes, it’s possible that savvy thieves can get your Social Security quantity — and a great deal of different details about you — someplace on-line. But don’t make it simple for them.
  7. Opt out of pre-screened bank card gives. Thieves can pluck these out of your mailbox and get a goldmine of personal info. Visit and cease them from being mailed to you.
  8. Never, ever give out your financial institution password or verification code. If somebody calls you and says, “We need you to tell us your password to verify that it’s you”; or “We just sent you a six-digit code — can you repeat it back to us for verification?”, hold up. No monetary establishment will ever ask for that info.
  9. Stop mail if you’re touring, and don’t let it linger in your mailbox. Minimize alternatives for thieves to get your personal info (or new checkbooks) out of your bodily inbox.
  10. Limit your digital presence. How a lot are you sharing, and the place? Are issues equivalent to your mom’s maiden identify or your hometown fairly simple to discern out of your Facebook profile? Lock down your profiles as a lot as potential, and suppose twice earlier than telling each web site that asks what your birthday is. If you need to take this to the subsequent stage, use a service equivalent toDeleteMe, which removes your personal info from knowledge aggregators (for a value).

What about me? Did I purchase identity theft insurance coverage?

Before I had my identity stolen, I’d have stated no. I didn’t suppose I used to be prone to being a sufferer, and figured I’d be capable of kind it out myself if I used to be. I used to be incorrect concerning the first half, and proper concerning the second half — however it got here on the expense of my sanity and numerous hours of unpaid and worrying work preventing automated financial institution maintain menus.

During open enrollment this year, I discovered my company is providing a well-liked identity theft insurance coverage coverage at a reduced group rate. I haven’t heard something from my thieves since 2020, however individuals who have been victims of identity theft earlier than are very prone to change into victims once more. I’m extra protected now as a result of I depart my credit score frozen, however I discovered by means of my reporting that there are loads of holes within the system that the thieves can squeeze by means of.

I requested Velasquez whether or not it would have saved me time and stress if I’d had a coverage again in 2019.

“It would have saved you an extraordinary amount of time,” she stated.

That’s all I wanted to listen to. I signed up.

About The Times Utility Journalism Team

This article is from The Times’ Utility Journalism Team. Our mission is to be important to the lives of Southern Californians by publishing info that solves issues, solutions questions and helps with choice making. We serve audiences in and round Los Angeles — together with present Times subscribers and various communities that haven’t traditionally had their wants met by our protection.

How can we be helpful to you and your group? Email utility (at) or one in all our journalists: Matt Ballinger, Jon Healey, Ada Tseng, Jessica Roy and Karen Garcia.

Back to top button