Scientology In Opening-Statement Spotlight – Deadline

With a jury lastly chosen and seated, Danny Masterson’s trial on a number of rape fees started in the present day with the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s office placing the Church of Scientology entrance and heart. 

From the start, Assistant DA Reinhold Mueller proclaimed the trial as “three different sexual assault cases, in fact three different case of forcible rape.”

With mere minutes to go earlier than the lunch break and after the prosecution had accomplished its opening assertion, protection lawyer Phillip Cohen gave a sign of the exhausting tone this trial might tackle. The lawyer leapt as much as give a “couple of highlights” of their argument, how the alleged victims disregarded the recommendation of the LAPD and communicated with each other and the way there was a shakedown at play as a result of Masterson made “oodles and oodles of money” on That 70s Show. There in a short time have been quite a lot of objections from Mueller and others on the prosecution desk as Cohen turned increasingly more aggressive, and a annoyed Judge Charlene Olmedo referred to as the events to the bench and may very well be heard telling them primarily to dial it down. 

“This case will also be about certain policies that each of these alleged victims understood they needed to follow,” Assistant D.A. Mueller instructed the courtroom earlier within the day of the David Miscavige-led group of which the That 70s Show star and the trio of victims on the coronary heart of the trial are or have been members of. “They acted in certain ways, they engaged in certain behavior and made certain choices …based on certain policies,” Mueller went on to say of the position of Scientology in Masterson’s life and case.  

As the prosecutor spoke late Tuesday morning, the alleged victims’ faces have been displayed on a video monitor on the far south wall of Olmedo’s courtroom in downtown Los Angeles. In reality, the big TV monitor was utilized steadily by Mueller as he ambled by means of the early phases of his opening assertion  

Starting with an outline of the alleged September 2002 rape by Masterson of an intoxicated “Jen B” in his Hollywood Hills residence, Mueller famous the complexity of the case and the exterior forces at play. Focusing on the sudden lack of friendships and extra that second era Scientologist “Jen B” suffered after telling others about what supposedly occurred with Masterson, Mueller admitted the alleged sufferer didn’t go to the police on the time and that she felt the incident, which can have resulted in a “pregnancy and a miscarriage” in consequence, was consensual.   

RELATED: Kevin Spacey Trial Opens As Harvey Weinstein, Danny Masterson, & Paul Haggis’ Sex Crimes Cases Head To Court

“What she didn’t believe was consensual was that he flipped her over and penetrated her anus,” Mueller acknowledged, moreover describing how “Jen B” got here to see the entire incident as non-consensual over time.  

As has been detailed in courtroom paperwork over the previous few years since Masterson was first arrested by the LAPD, a part of that change of thoughts by “Jen B” was one other alleged assault in April 2003. After consuming half of a glass of a “fruity” drink that Masterson made for her, “Jen B” mentioned she began to fell “woozy.” Originally intending simply to choose up some keys, “Jen B” was pulled over to a Jacuzzi and instructed that she had 15 seconds to disrobe earlier than he tossed her within the water.  

In the corresponding sequence of occasions, Masterson introduced he was taking an more and more nauseous “Jen B” upstairs to assist her vomit. Soon afterwards, based on the Assistant D.A., Masterson moved the out and in of consciousness “Jen B” into the bathe and, whilst she tried to combat him off, carried her into the following door master suite. It is then that the second sexual incident with Masterson occurred – an incident that noticed Masterson on high of her, penetrating her and smothering her with a pillow whereas telling her “you like this don’t you?” Instructing “Jen B” to not inform any of the individuals she instructed of the primary incident of this second assault, Masterson supposedly additionally yelled on the passing out “Jen B” to “don’t f*cking move, don’t f*cking move,” when there’s a knock on the door.  

Mueller mentioned that “Jen B” remained in the master suite, at one level hiding in a closet, till the morning of the following day, April 26, 2003. Missing her father’s birthday BBQ as a result of she was at Masterson’s home, “Jen B” didn’t later that day inform any of her household of what had occurred as a result of she was “incredibly upset and embarrassed about what happened.” Later on a household journey to Florida, bruises began to indicate on her physique and she or he did open up to a teenage member of her household components of what occurred at Masterson’s residence.  

It was at this level in his all of the sudden extra aggressive opening assertion, Assistant D.A. Muller actually flicked the swap on Scientology.  

“If you are going to tell me this is rape, it is not rape, “Jen B”s instant Scientology supervisor Julian Schwartz instructed her when she went to him with the matter, based on Mueller. “In fact, you are not even allowed to say the word rape. You are not allowed to go to police or anyone.” 

Schwartz allegedly made it clear to “Jen B” that if she did make any of what occurred public it might be contemplate “a high crime” in Scientology and she or he may very well be declared a “suppressive person. At a subsequent response in April 2004 from Scientology’s International Justice Chief also told “Jen B” she can be a SP in the event you went to the cops, which she was as soon as once more asking permission to do.    

Still, on June 6, 2006, “Jen B” went to the Hollywood LAPD station to inform them her story. Very quickly afterwards a meeting at “Jen B”s mum or dad’s residence noticed the younger lady pressured to signal an NDA and drop the matter or be primarily excommunicated, “Jen B” inked the doc for the Scientology lawyer allegedly in her mum or dad’s lounge, and a collection of funds adopted because the police case withered.  

In a tie and non-matching blazer and pants, Masterson watched within the close to silent courtroom as Mueller then detailed his relationship with “Christina B,” their relationship, and the more and more violent intercourse he supposedly compelled on her. “He spat on her face, he called her white trash, as he frequently did,” Mueller mentioned of Masterson’s therapy of the one-time mannequin after she tried to pressure him off her after one alleged assault 

As the jury, alternates, and members of Masterson’s household and mates seemed on within the packed and partially masked Department 105 courtroom, the prosecution rigorously planted the seeds of proof of Masterson seemingly drugging his victims, having “anal sex while you were unconscious,” and the swift strikes Scientology took to guard the extremely valued actor. In the case of “Christina B,” her Scientology advisors mentioned that somebody “can’t rape your 2B” a.ok.a. accomplice and the assault occurred due to one thing she has executed beforehand in her life. Interrupted by the protection at this level, the Assistant D.A. instructed the jury that Christina B was instructed by Scientology advisors that she was supposed to supply intercourse to Masterson at any time when he needed it as a result of he was such an enormous contributor and supporter to the church.

Around 11:30 AM PT, the protection objected once more to Mueller’s mentions of Scientology in his opening assertion and all of the attorneys have been referred to as as much as consult with the choose. When Mueller restarted his opening assertion he famous that “Christina B” and Masterson’s relationship resulted in March 2002, they usually did have two subsequent incidents of consensual intercourse. Still Christina B didn’t go to the police till 2016 

“All she really wanted was the church to intervene …to get some help for Mr. Masterson.” 

Clearly aiming to wrap up his presentation earlier than the lunch break, Mueller outlined the primary meeting between a “commanding” Masterson and “NT” within the early 2000s and the way she instructed him “no sex” She “begins to feel very buzzed” and “blurry,” Mueller mentioned of NT after a glass of wine or two at Masterson’s Hollywood Hills home. “Feeling scared,” NT was “ordered” by Masterson to go upstairs and “they end up in his bathroom shower.” She “recalls being in his shower, there was kissing,” and Masterson allegedly penetrated her earlier than taking the 2 of them into his bed room, as he did with “Jen B.” Graphically describing the compelled intercourse NT endured, Muller quoted from a deposition that she felt “like a little rag doll.” 

Taking pains to teach the jury on the “difficulties” rape victims can have “processing” what has occurred to them, Mueller famous they’ll study of the worry the victims had of the Church of Scientology.

Masterson was arrested in June 2020 on three counts of forcible rape that allegedly occurred in 2001 and 2003 at his Hollywood Hills residence. Out on $3.3 million bail, the Tom Mesereau-defended actor is a doable most sentence of 45 years to life in state jail if discovered responsible. Masterson, who was subsequently dropped from Netflix’s Ashton Kutcher co-starring comedy The Ranch on the finish of 2017 as claims turned recognized, has at all times denied he had nonconsensual intercourse with anybody.

Today’s opening statements come after virtually per week of jury choice on the ninth ground of the Clara Shortridge Foltz Criminal Justice Center. In a convergence of claimed crimes, Harvey Weinstein’s LA rape trial is going down on the different of the corridor within the downtown Los Angeles constructing. That case shouldn’t be anticipated to seat a jury till subsequent week on the earliest.

With the Church of Scientology looming massive over the Masterson trial, as was made evident in questioning of potential jurors yesterday, the anticipated two-month lengthy case in DTLA is anticipated to see witnesses similar to all 4 of the Jane Does, quite a lot of former Scientologists like Lisa Marie Presley, in addition to Hollywood heavyweight lawyer Marty Singer. The latter lawyer represented Masterson for a few years and was intimately concerned in efforts by the actor and his associates to finally unsuccessfully quell the accusations a number of years in the past.

Still, regardless of Judge Charlaine Olmedo’s phrases that this isn’t a trial about Scientology, the Church could be very a lot within the highlight right here with one in every of its most excessive profile members accused by ex-members of sexual assault.

That highlight can also be partially attributable to Scientology itself.  

The David Miscavige-led non-profit group was unsuccessful earlier this month in convincing the Supreme Court to get embroiled in its want to cease a number of former members of the church and alleged Masterson victims from taking them to trial on claims of surveillance, harassment and the killing of pets. The now revived go well with from 4 girls who’ve claimed they have been focused by Scientology after going to the LAPD a number of years again with their inital claims towards the actor has been paused pending Masterson’s legal case. Still, with the behind closed doorways “religious arbitration” effort and petition denied by SCOTUS, and former Scientologists among the many victims in Masterson’s trial, the strategies and potential complicity of the movie star wealthy Church will likely be exhausting pressed to not be proper close to the focus within the courtroom, now and down the road.

Earlier Tuesday, earlier than the D.A.’s office started their opening assertion, Judge Olmedo briefed the 19 jurors and alternates on what was going to occur and what was anticipated of them throughout the trial and deliberations. Explaining that opening statements are designed to put out “what the attorneys expect the evidence to show,” the choose additionally famous that the protection didn’t must current a gap assertion if they didn’t wish to. She additionally made a degree of noting that jurors are usually not allowed to debate the trial, the proof or any matter linked to the case with anybody together with “spiritual advisors or therapists.” This being LA and a celeb trial, the choose made a definite level of informing the jurors and alternates that whereas they’ll speak to anybody they need after the trial is full and verdict delivered, they’ve to attend 90 days beneath California legislation earlier than accepting compensation for books, broadcast or some other platform on the case.  

Erik Pedersen contributed to this report.

Back to top button