Progressives Are Starting To Freak Out About Dan Goldman In New York’s 10th District

NEW YORK ― It’s not usually that rival candidates for a similar public office convene a joint press convention.

But on Monday, Rep. Mondaire Jones and state Assembly member Yuh-Line Niou, each candidates for the Democratic nomination in New York’s newly drawn 10th Congressional District, did simply that in entrance of New York City Hall in decrease Manhattan.

Standing in entrance of a row of aides holding double-sided signs that stated “NYC is NOT for Sale” and “Anybody but Goldman,” the pair of progressives expressed concern concerning the risk that the race’s frontrunner, Dan Goldman, posed to town and the nation.

“Conservative Democrat Dan Goldman cannot be allowed to purchase this congressional seat, certainly not in one of the most progressive congressional districts in the country and not at a time when our democracy is in crisis,” Jones declared.

Niou provided an analogous message, whereas including a jab at different candidates who didn’t attend the occasion.

“We’re standing with the people,” she stated. “And it’s disappointing that more of the candidates in this race can’t make that commitment.”

“We are reaping the consequences of our failure to coordinate and coalesce.”

– A veteran progressive marketing campaign strategist

When pressed by reporters, neither Niou nor Jones would single out anybody by title for his or her absence.

The uncommon occasion was the primary actual signal that panic is setting in amongst left-leaning Democrats fearful that the Aug. 23 main for an open, liberal seat is slipping out of their grasp.

Goldman, a former federal prosecutor who led House Democrats’ impeachment of then-President Donald Trump in 2019, has used some $4 million of his inherited wealth to ascertain dominance on the tv airwaves. The most reasonable viable candidate in a crowded area of progressive rivals, he has loved a constant lead within the polls.

And on Saturday, Goldman landed the coup de grâce: The endorsement of the editorial board of the New York Times, an establishment with quasi-clerical authority within the prosperous, liberal precincts of decrease Manhattan and brownstone Brooklyn.

Now progressives who’re nonetheless reeling from the losses of Democratic Reps. Andy Levin (Mich.) and Marie Newman (Ill.) ― left-wing incumbents ousted in different redistricting-driven primaries ― are bracing themselves for disappointment in New York City, the positioning of their best triumphs in current reminiscence.

“The redistricting took people by surprise, but when we have open, safe blue seats like this, progressives need to get together and coalesce. We didn’t do that,” stated a veteran progressive marketing campaign strategist, who is just not concerned within the main however requested anonymity to protect skilled relationships. “And now we are reaping the consequences of our failure to coordinate and coalesce.”

With the resources to self-fund and the endorsement of the New York Times, Dan Goldman is in a strong position in the Democratic primary in New York's 10th Congressional District.
With the resources to self-fund and the endorsement of the New York Times, Dan Goldman is in a robust position within the Democratic main in New York’s 10th Congressional District.

Tom Williams/Getty Images

The MSNBC Candidate Finds His ‘Resistance Democrat’ Niche

Goldman’s defections from left-wing orthodoxy are obvious in a seat that President Joe Biden would have carried by over 53 percentage points.

Goldman is just not a proponent of Medicare for All, scholar debt cancellation or an enlargement of the Supreme Court, and he needed to stroll again a remark that he “would not object” to a state authorities limiting abortion on the level of fetal viability. When it involves international coverage, Goldman is unlikely to veer from the institution script by, for instance, utilizing his platform to criticize the Israeli authorities. And he refuses to promote his investments in News Corp, the mum or dad company of Fox News, underneath stress from his opponents. (Goldman additionally beforehand held a stake within the gun maker Sturm, Ruger & Co., though his marketing campaign stated he was unaware of it; it stated he was additionally unaware that his funding supervisor lately bought the stock.)

“Mr. Goldman is a hypocrite,” Jones stated on Monday. “He continues to invest in Fox News, the biggest disinformation machine this country has ever seen, while pretending to care about the state of our democracy.”

Goldman, who has promised to place his belongings right into a blind belief if elected and helps barring members of Congress from buying and selling shares, stated Monday that his document as a prosecutor is testomony to his integrity.

“Regardless of whatever stocks I may have owned, at the U.S. Attorney’s office, I took on corporations, I took on Wall Street banks,” he advised reporters at a press convention within the Financial District.

Whether Goldman’s explanations win over probably the most dedicated progressives could not matter. Like many closely Democratic districts, New York’s 10th is just not uniformly left-wing. And within the district’s deeply partisan, however usually fiscally conservative neighborhoods, Goldman’s résumé ― and his wealth and elite pedigree ― have been an asset.

Goldman parlayed his work because the lead impeachment counsel towards Trump right into a gig as a contributor on MSNBC. Especially within the wake of the FBI’s current raid of Trump’s Mar-a-Lago, the sorts of Democrats who watch MSNBC proceed to place a premium on Goldman’s chief promoting level: His professed expertise with, and dedication to, defending the United States’ democracy.

“It’s one of those rare districts where voters actually do care about democracy and impeachment.”

– Lis Smith, Democratic strategist

“It’s one of those rare districts where voters actually do care about democracy and impeachment,” stated Lis Smith, a Democratic strategist who lives within the West Village and is leaning towards voting for Goldman. “The district has strong ‘Resistance Democrat’ vibes.”

In addition, at a second when the general public is anxious about an uptick in crime, Goldman is working as a law-and-order Democrat who labored underneath the famed former U.S. Attorney ― and fellow liberal superstar ― Preet Bharara within the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.

A primary-time candidate free from the luggage of a voting historical past, Goldman casts himself as a champion for racial equality, gun management and abortion rights. A one-minute version of certainly one of his TV adverts informs viewers about his work underneath Bharara, his time throughout regulation faculty on a civil rights case at a naval shipyard, and the racial-disparity analysis he contributed to “The New Jim Crow” e book. The spot additionally options stills of him talking to Black voters and Asian voters, and a photograph of him posing alongside Eric Holder, the nation’s first Black legal professional common.

“Running through it all is his commitment to equal rights under the law,” the narrator intones because the digital camera pans throughout a photograph of him marching in an LGBTQ satisfaction parade.

Goldman’s opponents have centered on the benefit that his standing as an inheritor to the Levi-Strauss clothes fortune supplies him, noting the tens of millions he gave to his personal marketing campaign. With a net worth of between $64 million and $253 million, Goldman seemingly can be the wealthiest member of Congress.

In follow, the benefit that Goldman’s wealth supplied him is a little more delicate. As of Aug. 3, Goldman had contributed about $2 million of his personal money to his marketing campaign, which spent $2.5 millionslightly less than Jones’ marketing campaign had spent over that very same interval. Goldman chipped in another $2 million of his personal money within the intervening weeks of the marketing campaign.

But Goldman’s personal wealth seemingly served as a security web that enabled him to purchase up blocks of TV promoting early on with out worry of working out of money. While Jones beat him to the airwaves, Goldman was outspending him each week by a five-to-one margin or extra on common.

Jones, with finite resources, determined to save lots of up for a last-minute blitz: He had almost $2 million in unspent money available as of Aug. 3. By that point, he had already fallen behind in the polls.

Rep. Mondaire Jones (D-N.Y.), center, speaks alongside Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), left, in April 2021. Warren, who is also close with Niou, has not endorsed in Jones' race.
Rep. Mondaire Jones (D-N.Y.), heart, speaks alongside Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), left, in April 2021. Warren, who can be shut with Niou, has not endorsed in Jones’ race.

Tom Williams/Getty Images

No One Is Coming To Save The Left

Although he has led constantly in polling, Goldman has not decisively damaged away from the pack. With early voting already underway, he’s the selection of twenty-two% of “very likely” main voters, in contrast with 17% for Niou and 13% every for Jones and Rivera, in keeping with an independent, public poll launched late Monday afternoon. The New York Times endorsement got here out on the final day that the survey was carried out, suggesting his numbers might go increased nonetheless.

“The Times is rocket fuel in that district,” Smith stated. “It’s more important in NY-10 because it’s just a big crowd of people who don’t have really established brands.”

Regardless, a candidate with lower than one-quarter of the vote can’t take the lead in a race with simply two or three candidates. And the mere existence of a extra crowded area is an indictment of the progressive institutional ecosystem. In order for a progressive to win, motion energy brokers wanted to persuade fewer left-leaning candidates to run.

It’s not the primary time {that a} failure to consolidate has damage the left. In Massachusetts’ 4th Congressional District in 2020, a crowded progressive area cleared space for now-Rep. Jake Auchincloss, a reasonable former Republican, to prevail in a main with 22% of the vote. And in New York City’s Democratic mayoral main in 2021, supporters of Maya Wiley lamented the failure of left-leaning teams to coalesce behind her sooner, easing Eric Adams’ path to the mayoralty.

“The mayor’s race was an absolute debacle and an embarrassment for the left,” stated a mainstream Democratic strategist, who requested anonymity for skilled causes and isn’t concerned within the 10th District main. “Now you look at New York’s 10th, and the question has to be: What are any of these left-wing groups even worth any more?”

The group greatest outfitted to play the function of convener is the New York chapter of the Working Families Party, which endorsed Niou. Jones, Rivera and Assembly member Jo Anne Simon have all, at one level or one other, been endorsed by the New York WFP, suggesting that the group might have some sway if it inspired them to bow out.

“Not nearly enough people in this district know the dangerous, unrepresentative views of Mr. Goldman, to say nothing of his tactics to distort the democratic process, using millions of dollars of his inherited wealth.”

– Rep. Mondaire Jones (D-N.Y.)

Asked whether or not the WFP has plans to attempt to halt Goldman’s momentum, the group known as for progressives to rally behind Niou, however didn’t specify whether or not it meant voters or candidates.

“Dan Goldman’s views on abortion, health care, and so much more are out of step with this overwhelmingly progressive district,” Sochie Nnaemeka, the New York WFP’s state director, stated in a press release. “Progressives have a chance to stop Goldman from buying a Congressional seat with his inherited wealth, but we need to come together around our strongest candidate now ― and there’s no question that candidate is Yuh-Line.”

State Sen. Julia Salazar (D-N.Y.), the primary of the present crop of democratic socialists elected to New York state authorities, echoed that decision.

“Every New Yorker should be concerned that a billionaire can purchase a congressional seat instead of working to democratically represent them,” Salazar, who helps Niou, advised HuffPost. “I share that concern and that’s one reason why I support the only grassroots candidate in this race.”

Jones, a previous darling of the WFP, moved to Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn, from the suburbs after court-ordered redistricting put fellow Democratic Rep. Sean Patrick Maloney’s residence in the identical district. Maloney, chairman of the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, introduced plans to run in Jones’ seat. Rather than run towards Maloney ― and face a tough common election, too ― Jones selected to run in New York’s 10th, the place he has struggled to beat skepticism over his lack of ties to the district.

When requested on Monday, neither Niou nor Jones was prepared to entertain the thought of dropping out and endorsing one other candidate. While Jones trails Niou within the newest ballot, he has loads of causes to dismiss the suggestion. With the first election only a week away from concluding, he seemingly is the one contender with the monetary resources to bleed Goldman.

Jones begins his barrage towards Goldman on Tuesday with a TV ad attacking Goldman’s “dangerous views on abortion” and different offenses. A pair of digital ads amplify that critique and distinction Goldman’s investments in company bogeymen with Jones’ humble upbringing.

HuffPost requested Jones whether or not he would really like outstanding progressives resembling Sens. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) and Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.), and Reps. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) and Jamaal Bowman (D-N.Y.) ― all of whom have to date declined to weigh in on the race ― to make their views recognized within the curiosity of stopping Goldman.

“Not nearly enough people in this district know the dangerous, unrepresentative views of Mr. Goldman, to say nothing of his tactics to distort the democratic process, using millions of dollars of his inherited wealth,” Jones replied. “If the people you just named want to help clarify those stakes for the people in this district, then I personally would welcome them amplifying this information.”

HuffPost reached out to all 4 lawmakers to ask if they’re prepared to endorse somebody and if they’re involved concerning the prospect of a divided progressive area facilitating Goldman’s victory. None of them responded with details about an endorsement, or in any other case mirrored on the prospect of a Goldman win.

New York City Council member Carlina Rivera has roots on the left, but is now seen as too moderate by groups like the Working Families Party.
New York City Council member Carlina Rivera has roots on the left, however is now seen as too reasonable by teams just like the Working Families Party.

Mary Altaffer/Associated Press

A Third Way?

HuffPost caught up with candidate Rivera as she was starting a night of canvassing the closely Latino part of Sunset Park, Brooklyn. She would later meet up with two influential allies, Rep. Nydia Velázquez (D-N.Y.) and New York City Council member Alexa Avilés, a uncommon democratic socialist who is just not supporting Niou.

Rivera tried to be nonchalant about her causes for skipping Niou and Jones’ press convention earlier within the day.

“We were just focusing on voter contact,” Rivera stated. “That’s where I feel the best time is going to be spent.”

Rivera made clear, nonetheless, that she shares her rivals’ considerations about Goldman.“He’s given three different positions on abortion access in six weeks,” she stated. “I find that to be unacceptable.”

But when HuffPost requested Rivera whether or not she, fairly than Niou or Jones, is one of the best different to Goldman, she reverted to humility. “The people of NY-10 are gonna decide that on Aug. 23,” she answered.

Rivera later expressed frustration that the ballot that got here out on Monday was carried out in English and Mandarin, however not Spanish. Latinos make up 19% of the principally white district’s inhabitants, which can be 22% Asian American.

Rivera has cast a novel profile within the race ― and never simply because she is the one Latino candidate. With roots on the left, she is a supporter of Medicare for All, the Green New Deal and scholar debt cancellation, in addition to a champion of inexpensive housing improvement and non-police strategies for stopping violent crime.

But Rivera has shifted to the middle lately, elevating questions on her core convictions. In 2020, she joined left-wing council members in voting towards the New York City budget on the grounds that it didn’t reduce police funding sufficient. This year, having already entered the congressional race, she voted with moderates in favor of a price range that held police funding innocent whereas slicing funding to different businesses.

“Carlina is right there for them.”

– A mainstream Democratic strategist

Unlike those that consider that police funding should be decreased to make method for social spending, Rivera advised HuffPost that she now believes violence interruption packages and different policing options should be “complementary strategies to law enforcement.”

Rivera additionally has taken a moderate line on U.S.-Israel coverage, in distinction with Niou’s lukewarm support for the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions motion towards Israel. And Niou and her allies have criticized Rivera, Jones and Goldman for accepting donations from actual property executives.

At the identical time, Rivera’s help for housing improvement and climate resiliency projects, regardless of loud native opposition, have gained her the respect of mainstream liberals anticipating a progressive able to saying “no” to entrenched curiosity teams.

In addition, she has the help of a bunch of New York City elected officers, and the most labor union endorsements of any candidate. And the nice and cozy reception she acquired in Sunset Park spoke to her reputation among the many district’s Latino residents.

The mainstream Democratic strategist argued that if left-wing teams have been extra pragmatic, Rivera can be the apparent decide.

“Carlina is right there for them. And they’d rather get behind a severely flawed candidate in Yuh-Line who is just never going to win,” the strategist stated. “She’s too far outside the mainstream of the Democratic Party and this is not a [Democratic Socialists of America] district.”

But Velázquez, who excitedly bought pedestrians leaving a C Town grocery store on Rivera’s candidacy in Spanish, was unconcerned concerning the lack of progressive consolidation towards a well-funded, white candidate.

She had been by means of it earlier than ― in 1992, when redistricting prompted then-Rep. Steven Solarz (D-N.Y.) to run in a crowded area of Latino candidates, together with Velázquez.

He lost and I’m here,” she stated with amusing.

Back to top button