Brooklyn

Manhattan Supreme Court judge kicks Assembly map drawing back to embattled Independent Redistricting Commission

For anybody who might have thought this year’s state redistricting course of wasn’t lengthy and drawn-out sufficient, a courtroom choice handed down Thursday guarantees to hold the occasion going not less than into subsequent spring.

That choice was issued by New York County Supreme Court Judge Laurence Love, who determined state Assembly lines will be redrawn by the very same state Independent Redistricting Commission (IRC) that botched the mapping course of earlier this year. The fee should produce a brand new plan by April 2023, with the purpose of getting the strains in place for the subsequent spherical of Assembly elections in 2024.

It adopted a June ruling from a state Appeals Court that ordered the maps be redrawn for the 2024 cycle – maintaining the maps drawn by the state legislature in place for this year’s elections, after it took over the method from the IRC – tasking Love with figuring out how the maps ought to be redrawn for 2024. The suit that sparked the decision came from GOP political activists Gary Greenberg and Gavin Wax in addition to failed Democratic gubernatorial candidate Paul Nichols.

The complete state redistricting course of was thrown into disarray this previous spring when the Democrat-controlled state legislature took over the map-making course of after the IRC – which is made up of a good variety of Democrat and Republican appointees – twice failed to agree on a set of strains to ship Albany lawmakers. The Congressional and state Senate maps drawn by the legislature, excluding the Assembly strains, were then promptly challenged in Steuben County Supreme Court and had been finally thrown out by New York’s Court of Appeals.

The strains had been then reconfigured by a court-appointed particular grasp, who released the new maps in late May, simply in time to be used for this year’s Congressional and state Senate elections, which had been pushed back to August.

The Assembly maps had been challenged in a swimsuit across the time the particular grasp launched the brand new Congressional and state Senate plans.

But the three activists who introduced the swimsuit that led to Thursday’s ruling aren’t proud of kicking the map-making course of back to the IRC and can probably attraction, asking for a keep on Love’s choice. Greenberg stated as a lot in a tweet following the ruling.

“Love’s order should be appealed all the way back to the top court in Albany if need be,” Greenberg wrote. “Representative democracy, not gerrymandering by pols, must be the law of the land.”

Election lawyer Jerry Goldfeder, nonetheless, informed PoliticsNY he doesn’t suppose a lot of a possible attraction.

“God bless them,” Goldfeder stated. “Everybody has a right to go to court and appeal.”

Goldfeder additionally stated he believes Love made the proper choice by giving the fee one other shot on the course of, regardless that they dropped the ball within the first go-around.

“I think it’s a terrific idea,” Goldfeder stated. “I wish the Court of Appeals had done that with the congressional and state Senate lines instead of giving it to a special master who wasn’t from New York and had no idea about the needs of the people of the state. They are authorized to draw the lines and they should be given another opportunity as part of the process under the state constitution.”

Back to top button