San Diego

Ethnic Studies And Civics Need To Be Taught Together, Not Separately

Find out what’s taking place in San Diegowith free, real-time updates from Patch.

Ethnic research can educate our kids about their commonalities and their distinctive identities. Civics can educate them easy methods to work towards compromise. California’s plan, nonetheless, is for these classes to be taught individually. That is not sensible.

By Amanda Susskind

Amanda Susskind is the president of Constitutional Rights Foundation.

Find out what’s taking place in San Diegowith free, real-time updates from Patch.

Dan Schnur, Special to CalMatters

Dan Schnur teaches programs in politics, communications and management on the University of California, Berkeley, Pepperdine University and the University of Southern California.

In a time of elevated polarization and divisiveness, it’s critically essential for California’s younger individuals to be taught the important elements of a steady and profitable democracy. That’s why our state’s public colleges require our kids to be taught civics.

In a time of elevated hatred and intolerance, it’s equally important for younger individuals to be taught their very own cultural histories and heritage, in addition to these of others with whom they reside in essentially the most various communities we’ve got seen within the historical past of our planet. That’s why our state’s public colleges will quickly be required to show ethnic research.

If executed nicely, these curricula can serve each laudable and mutually reinforcing objectives.

Ethnic research can educate our kids about their commonalities and the distinctive nature of their identities.

Civics can educate them easy methods to reconcile their variations to work towards productive compromise.

California’s plan, nonetheless, is for these classes to be taught individually, with no effort to assist college students perceive the interdependency of those two essential matters. That is not sensible.

As California begins the method of creating ethnic research curricula, we in civic schooling have some concepts. We imagine an ethnic research program will be of immense worth, however provided that the curriculum contains civic studying methods and resources to assist college students establish, analysis, talk about and analyze essential points so as to take accountable, knowledgeable motion.

In high-quality civic learning, we all know that college students be taught to suppose critically, develop analysis expertise, assess and synthesize data and current coherent arguments primarily based on information.

We imagine that the mix of civic studying and ethnic research can restore our nation, our communities and our establishments to locations of civility, respect and integrity, dedicated to upholding the beliefs of our democratic rules.

As civic schooling advocates, we begin with the premise that every one California college students should be outfitted with the information, expertise and tendencies to learn residents. They want to know easy methods to discover frequent floor in our pluralistic society whereas defending the rights of our individuals no matter race, ethnicity, indigeneity, faith, gender, class, sexual orientation or different identities.

Because civic studying facilities on the continuous wrestle to make our nation “a more perfect union,” crafting efficient ethnic research packages can present the right context for civics to guard democratic beliefs, norms and practices. The institution of ethnic research requirements underscores our perception that an consciousness of being a part of an interrelated group equips college students to contribute to the general public good and helps strengthen democracy.

In truth, the state’s Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum describes how the sector of ethnic research contributes to the bigger purpose of making ready younger individuals to grow to be knowledgeable residents.

Ethnic research:

• Should assist college students grow to be extra engaged regionally and turn into efficient civic members and stronger social justice advocates, higher capable of contribute to constructive social change.


“CalMatters is an outstanding reliable news source. Adding an election guide is icing on the cake.”

-Anne, Newcastle

Make a tax-deductible donation

• Can assist college students be taught to debate tough or controversial points, notably when race and ethnicity are essential components.

• Provide a framework via which college students can develop civic participation expertise, a better sense of self-empowerment and a deeper dedication to lifelong civic engagement in the reason for better group and fairness.

• By emphasizing citizenship, ethnic research present college students with a eager sense of ethics, respect and appreciation for all individuals, no matter ethnicity, nationality, gender, sexual orientation, means, faith and beliefs.

We assist initiatives to make sure that all college students, starting in kindergarten, are supplied high-quality studying alternatives that put together them to learn, expert, empathetic, respectful, lively and engaged residents.

We urge colleges to incorporate civic studying as an integral part of the newly mandated ethnic research program. Our younger individuals ought to be happy with their heritage and have fun their variations. But they have to additionally perceive that our future success will depend on their means to work collectively and grow to be engaged members in our democracy.


Dan Schnur has written beforehand about a bill requiring Donald Trump to disclose his tax returns, Proposition 13 and Sen. Dianne Feinstein.

We wish to hear from you

Want to submit a visitor commentary or response to an article we wrote? You can discover our submission guidelines here. Please contact CalMatters with any commentary questions: [email protected] is a nonprofit, nonpartisan media enterprise explaining California insurance policies and politics. Sign up for our newsletters and comply with us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.

Back to top button