Abortion floor debate splits South Carolina Republicans

COLUMBIA, S.C. — The South Carolina Senate’s three Republican ladies all stated Wednesday that they may not help an abortion ban that didn’t embrace exceptions for pregnancies attributable to rape or incest.

Two totally different makes an attempt to get the exceptions again into the invoice failed later within the day. Senators adjourned Wednesday night with out a closing vote.

Republicans are dealing with off in opposition to each other over the ban. On one aspect is a core group that views any abortion as ending a life. On the opposite are conservatives who’ve digested developments elsewhere since Roe v. Wade was overturned and say they do not need 14-year-old rape victims to have to provide delivery or pressure a mom to hold to time period a fetus unable to stay exterior the womb.

Democrats are principally letting them argue amongst themselves, refusing to assist extra average Republicans and preserving the invoice as strict as doable to attempt to defeat it.

Senators have been instructed the proceedings may final days. If the laws is accredited and signed into regulation, South Carolina would be part of Indiana as states which have handed near-total abortion bans for the reason that Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in June.

If the invoice passes, it can return to the House, which accredited a model final week with rape or incest exceptions as much as the twelfth week of pregnancies.

A primary vote to attempt to add again the exceptions as much as the twentieth week of being pregnant was rejected 23-6. None of the Senate’s Democrats voted. A second try to permit abortions for pregnancies attributable to rape or incest as much as six weeks after conception failed 23-18 as many Democrats did lastly vote, following their technique to preserve the ban as absolute as doable.

The three Republican ladies within the Senate rose early within the debate and spoke back-to-back, saying they can not help it until the rape and incest exceptions are restored.

“Are we simply baby machines? Are you pregnant with a dead baby? Too bad. Raped at 11 by your grandfather and got pregnant? That’s just too bad,” Sen. Penry Gustafson stated.

Gustafson watched because the Senate’s longest-serving lady, Sen. Katrina Shealy, stated the 41 males within the Senate can be higher off listening to their wives, daughters, moms, granddaughters and nieces.

“Yes, I’m pro-life. I’m also pro-life for the mother, the life she has with her children who are already born. I care about the children who are forced into adulthood, made up by a Legislature full of men so they can feel good about it,” Shealy said.

Senators who support the ban said the state needs to show it values all life by taking advantage of the opening created by the U.S. Supreme Court.

Sen. Richard Cash compared abortion to slavery Tuesday, asking if “the human being in the womb is nothing more than the property of a woman?”

“Does an unborn human being have essentially the most basic civil proper of all, which is the suitable to life?” stated Cash, who has made ending abortion his chief focus in 5 years within the Senate.

The similar invoice with out the exceptions appeared to fail within the extra conservative state House final week earlier than some Republicans maneuvered by means of a collection of votes to permit abortions for rape and incest victims as much as the twelfth week of being pregnant.

Senators did agree to alter the invoice to permit abortions when a health care provider determines a fetus has a severe medical downside and won’t survive exterior the womb, and to permit dependents to get contraception if their mother and father get insurance coverage by means of the well being plan for state staff.

The invoice would ban all abortions in South Carolina besides when the mom’s life is in danger. Before they have been eliminated, the invoice additionally included exceptions for pregnancies attributable to rape or incest, permitting abortions as much as 12 weeks after conception. In these circumstances, the physician would have needed to inform the affected person that the crime and the abortion might be reported, together with her identify given to the county sheriff inside 24 hours of the process.

South Carolina at present has a ban on abortions as soon as cardiac exercise in a fetus is detectable, which is often about six weeks. But that regulation has been suspended because the South Carolina Supreme Court opinions whether or not it violates the state’s constitutional proper to privateness. That leaves South Carolina’s older 20-week abortion ban as the present benchmark.


Follow Jeffrey Collins on Twitter at

Back to top button